Quote
If humans have been to a given place, I can see the logic in making assertions based on evidence. However, I cannot understand humans making assertions on places that cannot be sensed. In fact all observations made of deep space by human have been made from our solar system and based on assumptions that have only been tested in and around Earth.
That still doesn't change the fact that the assertion you made about the nature of space should only hold in the couple of points where humans have actually been in orbit and done experiments. For all we know, according to your logic, the space not surrounding the Earth and the moon might actually filled with some sort of perfectly transparent jelly that we only don't know about because we haven't been there to observe. In which case, your argument 'space is near a vacuum' wouldn't hold. I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just saying you're not consistent. If you were consistent, you'd prefix that statement with 'for all the points in space where humans have done experiments or made observations, we know space is near a vacuum, but we don't have any idea about any of the other points that we haven't directly observed, and we don't know if anything's changed since we last did the measurements.'
Quote
And just because it wasn't meant specifically to be a personal attack doesn't mean the five posts before, noting and an obvious slight error in my statement that everyone understood was an error, didn't deserve a rebuttal. For some reason the post berated, and made accusations, of me trying to disprove the Law of Thermodynamics. Obviously it was a slight error..that was fixed.
So berate the first four people who made fun of you, not the fifth person who skimmed through the posts, read carefully the last two out of four, and corrected a mistake in the logic of the post right above him. Are you going to read any other conspiracies into my post? :rolleyes:
Quote
Still, my point stands. It is not known whether the law of thermodynamics is in fact uniform through out the universe. It may be relative, we don't know, because there may be factors outside our solar system that affect thermodynamics in weird and unforeseen ways.
From a philosophical stance, I don't have any argument with that statement. Which is cool, because that's not what I was saying to begin with.
Anyways, I think we've derailed this thread enough (again), not because you really had any problem with what I was asserting about science, but because you didn't bother to read my posts. PM me if you want to take this any further.
This post has been edited by UE_Research & Development: 19 January 2008 - 10:57 AM