Quote
Originally posted by Count Altair El Alemein:
For a short time (about 5 days) it was the highest rated thing on the entire board, succeeded only by Space Marines, Net. But there is something else. The Ares community is basically irresponsible when it comes to voting. I mean, Iron Fist is arguably the best plug out at the moment, and what is it rated? 60-ish. Just look at it, it's disgraceful. I imagine there are a bunch of jerks that go around the net, and when they see something rated 100 they think 'ah, I don't think it deserves that' for no reason and give it a 1. I should know because I did that to all the other plugins so Earth Quest could get up top.
This happens to nearly all plugs. When all three of the plugs I've submitted, Aaaagh!, The Rogue, and Vengeance, were released, their first ratings were all 100, and now only Vengeance has a decent rating. Pretty much all plugs seem to go through this process. Also, most good plugs seem to be rated 60ish in the Ares addons, because of my next point.
Quote
Originally posted by Count Altair El Alemein:
There is also a more psychological reason. In EV you can go there and see, i.e. Frozen Heart, which deserves to be at the top or whatever and is there. This is because, in EV it is much harder to make plugins, and so people don't feel any need to reduce the competition a bit. On the other hand, in Ares, bascially everyone has atleast tried Hera, and so therefore that gives them a subconscious reason to envy other people's plugs and give them low scores just for the 'ell of it.
Actually, most people with the ability to use plugs (1.2.0b6) seem to get scared of Hera the first time they try it, or they just want the beta for the plugs. I do agree that there are plenty of jerks out there that will try to rate plugs low. For this reason, you should be sure to check the plug's description and number of downloads before you decide whether or not you want to play it.
Quote
Originally posted by Count Altair El Alemein:
If there is anyone there with the power to change the add-ons section, this is what I recommend. When you click 'rate it' you must first submit your reasons and then moderators evaluate it.
The only place where there's something like this is Patrick's review site, where you send him an email containing your review and he puts it up. However, he doesn't have many plugs in it, and not many people know about his site. I think that a link posted at the top of the addons to his reviews site would be a very good idea. We'll have to see what the mods think.
------------------
"I am the supreme dictator of the universe, it's just that nobody knows about it yet."
"Never do today what you can put off until tomorrow."