Quote
Originally posted by Sargatanus:
**Hey, I've got this wild idea: Instead of saying "Shut up, Sargatanus. What you're saying is totally wrong and completely self-contracicting," how about pointing out where I'm wrong. It would help me out a lot.
(Sorry if anyone is offended by this, but I'm in a realy bad mood after work. Besides, I HATE it when people tell I'm wrong without telling me how and why.)
**
I apologize if I ever come across as rude. I can only assure you that it was never my intention to offend you.
But I am curious about the following:
**Humans: Got a message telling them to send a large ship with a large population to a distant system. They do so, only to discover that it was a ploy by the Ishimans (covered next) to save them from the Cantharans (covered later). The humans get really pissed that their planet was stolen, and start a war. The humans that stayed on Earth expanded their space a little, gaining three extrasolar colonies before the invasion of the Cantharans.
**
- How do you know what the message says?
- The word "ploy" usually has a negative connotation. Are you suggesting that the Ishiman proposal (assuming that you do know the contents of the message) is some kind of trick?
**Ishimans: Zookeepers of the galaxy. With their holier-than-thou attitude, they preserve 'primitave' and 'endangered' civilizations on replacement planets or a Topopolis (tubeworld, kind of like cosmic spaghetti). The Ishimans, after a severe tounglashing by the captain of the Apollo, provided the Ares (new name of the Apollo) crew with the hardware to win Earth back from the Cantharans. The Ishimans were crippled in a battle with the Audemedons (covered later) in the Lalande system, losing a signifigant portion of their military equipment.
**
- Again, "holier-than-thou" also has a negative connotation, implying arrogance. I am wondering whether this is simply your interpretation rather than a fact? After all, one can interpret their exchange with the humans in the introductory text as sincere.
- How do you know that the Ishimans have "Topopolis?"
- The introductory text suggests that the Ishimans went along the plan beccause they saw it to their advantage. You imply that somehow their conscience was reawakened after a "tongue-lashing."
- I also wonder about your point regarding the Ishimans suffering heavy losses at Lalande.
**Cantharans: A former trading empire and forger of peace, the Cantharan Order was racked by the Boodan Civil War, which saw the rise of the Salrilian backed Boodan Zealots. The Zealots used asteroids laced with a biomechanical virus to gain control of planets, and eventually took control of the order, and soon began a massive expansion campaign in the name of the gods Zom and Doz to increase "enlightenment." Although it is speculated by the Ishimans that this expansion has more to do with followung the paths of the virus ridden asteroids than it does with enlightenment. Due to increasing belligerance, the Cantharans were eventually diplomatically excommunicated by most of the galactic powers, with the exception of the Gaitori, Salrilians, and Audemedons.
**
- How do you know of the existence of Boodan Zealots?
- How do you know they were backed by Salrilians?
- How do you know that the Zealots used those special asteroids to gain control of planets? (especially considering that the text following the conclusion of chapter 7 suggested that this method of delivery is probably too slow)
- How do you know that those Zealots gained control of the Order?
- As I recall, the game itself only mentioned Elejeetians and Ishimans breaking off diplomatic relations. It never mentioned the Bazidanese or the Obish doing the same. Therefore I am at a loss as to how you can describe the Cantharans as being "diplomatically excommunicated by MOST of the galactic powers." (emphasis mine)
**Gaitori: Once a powerful trading empire, the Gaitori Union is now little more than sentry to their economic supporters, the Cantharans. At one point, the Gaitori had the potential to be a huge militry power. At the height of this potential, they were engaged in a cataclysmic war with the Obain (covered later), which the Union was slowly winning. The tide of the war was turned however, when the Salrilians provided the Obain with cloaking technology. To this day, the Gaitori bare a deep hatred for the Salrilians, but can take no action due to their loyalty to the Cantharan Order.
**
- "(E)conomic supporters" imply that the Cantharans provide grants or loans to help the Gaitori economy and government. How do you know that such economic assistance is being provided?
- How did you know that the Gaitori had "potential to be a huge military power?"
- How do you know they fought the Obish at the height of such potential? (assuming that they indeed had that potential)
- How do you know that it was a cataclysmic war?
- How do you know that they were slowly winning?
- How do you know that the Salrilians provided the Obish with their stealth field technology then and not earlier or later?
- If you cannot answer 6), then am I right to assume that your statement about their hatred of Salrilians becomes invalid as well?
**Bazidan: The Bazidan Star leuge is a current trading empire (this is how most galactic powers get their start, and some make a permanant job of it). The Bazidan are an economic backbone for any bergeoning (sp?) power, and are renowned for their patience. The limit to this patience was found when the Star leuge was being harassed constantly by Cantharan raids, and sunsequently, the Bazidan provided equipment to the Ares crew and the Ishimans.
**
- How do you know that a trading empire "is how most galactic powers get their start?"
- How do you know that they were "harassed CONSTANTLY" (emphasis mine) by Cantharan raids? Chapter 14 is more like an invasion rather than a raid since the Cantharans took possession of the Bokleo Ststem. Incidentally, Chapter 14 is also the only chapter where a Bazidanese outpost was attacked in the entire game. Your use of the plural form of "raid" suggests that there was more than one of them.
**Elejeetians: One of the oldest and arrogant species in the known galaxy. The Elejeetians rarely demonstrate their amazing militry potential. However, after a Salrilian raid on the Banadee, the liner ferring Minister Jommo, they were compelled to assist the Ishimans and the Ares crew.
**
- How do you know they were one of the oldest? In addition, to make that judgment implies knowledge of which races appeared first and which ones appeared later. Can you please make a list of which ones are older than others? On what basis can you make that list?
- Why do you claim that they are "arrogant?"
- The use of "compelled" suggests that they were forced to fight after the attack on the Banadee. However, the introduction to Chapter 13 suggests that they were an old enemy of Cantharans. Another possibility is that the attack on the Banadee gave them the excuse to start a war with the Cantharans.
**Salrilians: The puppet masters of the galaxy, and most likely the oldest. The Salrilians are obsessed with predicting and controling destiny, and are said to have the ability to predict the future. This ability is far from supernatural however. Through a series of millions quantum computers spread throughout their space processing all the information they can get known as the Oracular Net, the Salrilians can easily predict any event in the galaxy. According to Salrilian proverb, an unknown factor is the most dangerous. Thus, they spend considerable resources into the research of other species. This research is conducted primarily in deep space simlabs. The Salrilians are the master race of both the Cantharans and Audemedons, and will exploit both of them freely to make sure that their predictions come to fruition.
**
- How do you make the judgment that they are "most likely the oldest?"
- How do you know that there are "millions" of quantum computers?
- Where did the Salrilian proverb come from?
- Your description of the Salrilian relationship with the Cantharans and Audemedons imply a one-way exploitation relationship? From what basis do you make this judgment? How do you know it is not a mutually beneficial symbiotic relationship? (a.k.a. "I scratch your back, and you scratch mine.")
**Audemedons: A race of sentient machines built and abandoned long ago by an unknown race. The Audemedons' technology in amazingly advanced, surpassed only by that of the Elejeetians. The Audemedons' central consciousness was assimilated some 1,000 years ago by the Salrilian Oracular Net, and now serve as Salril's elite guard.
**
- How do you know they were abandaoned?
- How do you know that Elejeetian technology surpasses Audemedon?
- How do you know their central consciousness was assimilated by the Salrilian Oracular Net?
- How do you know the time that was accomplished?
I hope that my incessant questioning doesn't come acroos as rude. If it does, I apologize again. It is not my intention. My intention is to establish events that occurred prior to Ares. (Why do you think I take so much time to write so long a story on events prior to Ares if not for my curiosity?)
If someone asks me how I know the details of my story, I will readily admit that I don't. Only a tiny fraction of the details come from Ares. A significant portion comes from my personal speculation and extrapolation. The majority comes from my over-active imagination. I don't claim that my story had any basis in Nathan Lamont's ideas.
Therefore I am particularly interested when someone claims that their source is Nathan Lamont himself. (I know you didn't make that claim in your post. I am simply trying to make a point and putting those people on notice.)
As for your post, I believe my 31 questions can be further condensed into the following: How many of your details are from legitimate courses (namely, the game itself and Nathan Lamont himself)? How many of it are from your own speculations and extrapolations? How many of it are from your own imagination?
Again, I can't emphasize enough the point that I bear no hostile intentions towards you or anyone else. The reason why I am making such a lengthy inquiry is because you opened yourself to questions. If "No thing" also opens himself to questions, he can expect to also get a list of inquiries from me (which will probably be an even longer list since his post included even more details).
Finally, if for any reason you consider my questions offensive, I apologize and remind you that you are under no obligations whatsoever to respond.
Sincerely,
htjyang