As I just posted over in JoshTigerheart's thread on the Nova board, I think the reactions he's getting are a good sign.
View PostDr. Trowel, on Apr 12 2007, 10:23 AM, said:
A while back, when people posted should-I-release-the-plug-early-even-though-it-doesn't-include-everything-I've-dreamed-of-or-go-for-the-grand-slam-OMG-uber-plug-that-will-take-a-lot-more-work threads, I often felt I was in the minority in recommending releasing sooner and smaller. I'm hoping that this means that today's community has more realistic appetites, and that that will mean more releases.
There are a bunch of awesome TCs out there that would be awesome and available if their developers had been able to curtail their ambitions, either at the start or along the way. I understand the importance of being true to one's art, and that that is a personal decision. Still, sometimes (often!) great art dies because an artist can't bear to release it less-than-perfect, even when it's already brilliant.
We need more Terek E'Bans, Guys, Paces, and CaptJoshes, by the way -- people willing to contribute by leveraging the contributions of others (with permissions where appropriate, of course). There are existing plugs that would benefit from being combined, old plugs and scenarios worth updating, and existing game universes (EVN, EVO, EVC, even Polycon!) worth writing for.
As for the "public alpha" concept that Pace raised in his initial post, and that originated with UncleTwitchy.... Obviously I'm a fan. I tried to do something similar with Voidspace as well and, while posting incomplete builds on an easily-discoverable-but-not-overly-traffic-heavy board (the old EV Void) didn't get me to be as diligent as I had planned to be about posting updates, it did keep me motivated at at least an above-zero level.