#1 for me: Pale all the way! The only problem is that I've done all the missions quite a few times, and it's getting boring. But it's really well designed and balanced. He did a good job of working old and new things together (Capital ship cannons, military versions of civilian armaments, pirate-modified vessels, etc.). But now, because of all the little tweaks Soul has made, I get less enjoyment from other plugs.
Other good ones: Final Battle (fun but buggy), New Horizons (nice missions), EVES (not done yet but great so far), EVGE (good all-around).
I don't really like Frozen Heart as much as most people do. That's mostly because it's so similar to the original EV universe while trying to be different. The ships themselves are almost all exact copies, as are their weapons (ie Rigellian Gunboat=Confed Gunboat). It's a good plot, if hard to pick up on sometimes, but the mechanics are equal to those of EV. I prefer ones that either completely change the galaxy's layout or use the existing one, but not a "warped" one.
About the Star Wars plug-ins: They are very inaccurate, as people have mentioned, and very buggy as well. Well, you can't expect much from it, considering Kris Hauser used it only as a means to show off his amazing 3D skills to the EV community.
------------------
Luca Rescigno
"And may not every one of the stars or suns have as great a retinue of planets with moons to wait upon them as has our own Sun?"
-Christiaan Huygens